The Classification and Coding of
Misfortune and Good Fortune
In the preceding three sections emphasis has been placed upon the various
interactions and activities of the characters. They may fight, dance, make
love, converse, walk around, look, listen, or struggle to accomplish
something. All of these acts involve some deliberate, voluntary choice on the
part of the character engaging in them. As the result of these acts,
characters may be killed, hurt, or defeated, or they may become engaged,
popular, or prosperous. These bad and good outcomes are, therefore, the
consequences of what the characters have done or attempted to do.
It sometimes happens that bad or good outcomes occur to a character
independent of anything he or she may have done. Fate, in a sense, has
stepped in and produced certain results over which no character has any
control. We have labeled these impersonal "fatalistic" events as misfortunes,
where bad things happen to a character, and good fortunes, where good things
happen to a character.
We shall first deal with misfortune (Scoring symbol: M). A misfortune
is any mishap, adversity, harm, danger, or threat which happens to characters
as a result of circumstances over which they have no control; it happens to
them through no fault of their own. A misfortune differs from the consequence
of an aggressive act, since in an aggression there is an intent by one
character to harm another character. There is no such intent in a misfortune.
A misfortune also differs from a failure, as was pointed out in the last
chapter. In a misfortune a person is not trying to do anything; rather,
something "bad" happens "out of the blue." The six subclasses of misfortune
are listed below.
- M6: A character is dead or dies as a result of
accident or illness or some unknown cause. Death because of murder is
categorically excluded because it is coded as an aggression.
- "I went up to the coffins and opened them. Lying in one box was my mother, in the other my sister, and in the third my brother. They all appeared TO BE DEAD."
- "I was attending my FATHER'S FUNERAL."
- M5: A character is injured or ill. This class includes
pain, operations, any bodily or mental defects, insanity, amnesia, blindness,
etc. Plastic surgery is not counted as an "operation" because it is elective
- "Her baby boy had a serious congenital HEART DEFECT."
- "My mother LOST HER MEMORY."
- "A TOOTH BROKE OFF in my mouth."
- "He had a CLUB FOOT."
- "My boyfriend had a STOMACHACHE."
- M4: A character is involved in an accident without
suffering physical or mental injury; a character loses a possession or has
one destroyed or damaged; a character has a defective possession.
- "As I was driving down the mountain, my car CRASHED BECAUSE OF THE ICY ROAD."
- "The DIAMOND CAME OUT of my engagement ring."
- "The LIGHTNING DAMAGED our house."
- "My boyfriend's car had a FLAT TIRE."
- M3: A character is threatened by something in the
environment. A threat of falling is classified under the next heading.
- "The wall began to crack and bulge out and I thought it was GOING TO FALL
- "The waves were very high and I was afraid the boat we were in WAS GOING TO CAPSIZE."
- M2: A character is falling or is in danger of falling.
- "I dreamed that I WAS FALLING AND FALLING and never hit bottom."
- "As I stood on the edge of the cliff, the rocks began to move and I WAS AFRAID I MIGHT FALL."
- M1: A character encounters an environmental barrier or
obstacle: a character is unable to move: a character is lost; a character is
late or is in danger of being late. This class of misfortunes includes
situations which produce frustration for the character who confronts them. In
some cases, the frustrating agent is clearly environmental in origin as when a
road is washed out; in other cases, where the character is lost or late, it is
possible that the character has made a contribution to the difficulty he or
she encounters. However, since the character has not consciously or
intentionally produced the difficulty and views the problem as external to
himself or herself, it seems more appropriate to treat it as a misfortune
that bears upon the character, rather than as a failure in achievement or as
an intropunitive aggression. Having encountered the obstacle which warrants
the M1 coding, it is possible for success or failure to be coded if the
character makes an effort to overcome the barrier and the outcome is
described in the dream report.
- "When we reached the river, we discovered that the BRIDGE HAD COLLAPSED so we couldn't get to the picnic grounds."
- "As the truck bore down on me, I tried to run but found that MY LEGS WOULDN'T MOVE."
- "I started toward home but the streets became more and more unfamiliar until I finally realized that I WAS LOST."
- "As I entered the office, I saw that I WAS LATE FOR WORK."
Good fortune is the opposite of misfortune. A misfortune is coded when
"something bad" happens to a character; a good fortune is coded when
"something good" happens to a character. The "something good" is not the
result of an intentional beneficial act by another character. That
would be coded as friendliness. Neither is the "something good" the result of
any purposeful striving by the character. That would be coded as success. A
good fortune is coded when there is an acquisition of goods or something
beneficial happens to a character that is completely adventitious or the
result of a circumstance over which no one has control. A good fortune is
also coded if the dreamer is in a bountiful environment. In a word, it might
be said that a good fortune is coded whenever a character becomes "lucky."
Good fortunes are rather rare in dreams. As the result of their paucity, we
have not attempted to subclassify them and code for only one class of good
fortune. The coding symbol is GF.
"I dreamed I FOUND A LOT OF MONEY."
"My girl friend WON ONE OF THE DOOR PRIZES."
"I was out hunting when a LARGE HERD OF DEER JUST SEEMED TO APPEAR from out of nowhere."
"I dreamed I WAS LIVING IN A MANSION, HAD CLOSETS FULL OF NEW CLOTHES, AND WAS DRIVING A NEW ROLLS-ROYCE."
Coding Procedures for Misfortune and Good Fortune
The coding procedure is essentially the same as that followed for success and
failure. A comma is placed after the coding symbol for the misfortune or good
fortune, and then the coding symbols for the characters are shown. Multiple
characters are joined by a plus sign.
|"I LOST MY WATCH over the side of the boat."
|"My buddy and I FOUND A BRAND NEW BOAT that had drifted up on the beach."
|"My teenage brother and my new baby sister both CAME DOWN WITH THE MUMPS."
- 1. Score each misfortune that happens to the same character when
the misfortunes belong to different subclasses.
|"My brother's car WAS WRECKED and HE GOT CUTS ON HIS FACE and broke his arm in the accident."
- 2. Score each misfortune or good fortune -- even those that belong
to the same subclass of misfortune -- if they happen to the same character at
different times in the dream.
|"I was hungry and began to scratch my nose. All of a sudden A STEAK SUPPER APPEARED in front of me. I ate this and after awhile I scratched my nose again. Suddenly I WAS DRESSED IN THE FINEST OF CLOTHES. I began to wonder if my nose were magic."
|"I was skiing when I ran into a tree and CUT MY LIP. I went back to the lodge and put a Band-Aid on it. Then I started out again. This time I SPRAINED MY ANKLE when one of my skis came off."
Coding the Consequences of Misfortune and Good Fortune
In the last section, it was indicated that consequences can occur which would
modify the initial achievement outcomes. In a similar fashion, the coding
system for misfortune and good fortune includes provisions for consequences
which alter the initial fate bestowed on a character. Three subclasses of
consequences have been developed. These consequences are either a form of
social interaction, an achievement outcome, or the opposite type of
fatalistic event. They are also coded independently of their coding as a
consequence. Their coding as a consequence is indicated by enclosing the
relevant coding symbol in parentheses following the coding unit. The purpose
of coding as a consequence is to preserve the sequence of events in order to
answer certain dynamic questions which might be raised. Such questions might
ask, "How often does a character struggle to overcome a misfortune and
succeed?" or "In what percentage of good fortunes does fate intervene and
turn an initial blessing into some misfortune?"
It should be noted that many researchers using the Hall/Van de Castle
scoring system do not bother to record consequences of success and failure,
since they occur so rarely; also, they can make a bit of a mess of your
Consequences of Misfortune
- 1. The misfortune is transformed into a good fortune.
|"My mother was very sick but ALL OF A SUDDEN SHE APPEARED WELL AND HEALTHY."
- 2. The character suffering the misfortune tries to cope with the
misfortune and succeeds.
|"The door was locked and wouldn't open. After trying several times, I finally used a bent hairpin and MANAGED TO GET IT OPEN."
- 3. Another character intervenes in a friendly fashion and dispels
|"I was hopelessly lost in the woods and wandering around in circles. Suddenly a man I had never seen before appeared and SHOWED ME THE WAY OUT OF THE WOODS."
Consequences of Good Fortune
- 1. The good fortune is transformed into a misfortune.
|"I found a lot of money but on my way home IT DISAPPEARED."
- 2. The character to whom the good fortune occurs tries to press his
or her luck and fails.
|"I dreamed I had found a lot of money. I invested it in order to make more money but THEN I LOST IT ALL."
- 3. Another character intervenes in an aggressive fashion and
intentionally destroys the good fortune.
|"My teenage sister found this real cute puppy but my father said SHE COULDN'T KEEP IT."
(Return to top)
Go back to the coding rules index.
Move on to the coding rules for emotions.